A Multi-Game Comparison The Settlers of Catan

Plenty of people have done an admirable job of explaining the games in their reviews, so this is instead an attempt at a comparison between a number of games, the pros and cons of each and which may suit different people best. The games in question are: Carcassonne, Settlers of Catan, Castle Panic, Smallworld, and Forbidden Island.

We have had Settlers of Catan and Carcassonne (with a number of expansion packs) for quite a few years now, and only recently added the other games above. We usually either play just as two adults, or with our two older children (age 9 and 8), and so our conclusions are based on how these games work in those settings. So here's what we've found:

Settlers of Catan
We got this around the same time as Carcassonne and initially just didn't latch onto it. Partly it's that it's supposed to be 3 players or more, and we often play as just two of us. Once we found online some instructions for playing as 2 players it came out more often, and as time's gone by it's become fairly 50-50 whether we play Settlers or Carcassonne on a quiet night in. The choice will usually depend on how much we want to think. With Settlers, you're always planning and calculating; with Carcassonne, you're taking it a card at a time.

Who should get it: Settlers is well-known as one of the great modern games. I'm not as sold on it as some people, and it takes quite a while to learn and feel comfortable with, but once you get the hang of it, it is an entertaining and enjoyable addition to a games collection. There are several 2-player rule variations out there if you need them and they work well (we found one that worked for us and we've stuck to it). But this isn't a game for kids; I would suspect not until they're 16 or so. Amongst other things, I think they'll find it too dull.

Carcassonne
This has been a favorite for years now, and everyone we've played it with has gone off to get it themselves. We usually play without farms because it then becomes less directly competitive and more sociable. Kids can play it, adults can play it, it's relaxed, it's fun and it's simple to learn. Here's one nice thing about it: you don't have to be constantly thinking and planning ahead. You don't know what card you're going to draw next time, so you just play one card at a time. You're encouraged to discuss where to put a card, and since you don't know what piece you're getting next, your comments to another player are usually pretty unbiased.

Who should get it: In my experience, pretty much anyone, except those who want ultra-competitive games. The first few expansion packs are also well worth getting, but don't bother with anything from Mayor onward.

More :

Buy Low Price legowhitecapbay4194
Buy Low Price brightstartsbounceaboutactivitycenter
Buy Low Price twilightimperium3rdedition
Buy Low Price lioneltrainspolarexpresstrainsetogauge
Buy Low Price alexreadysetgoredtrike
Buy Low Price plantoybabywalker
Buy Low Price unclemiltonstartheatrepro
Buy Low Price elencosnapcircuitssc750rstudenttrainingp
Buy Low Price elencosnapcircuitssc750rstudenttrainingp
Buy Low Price southshorefurnituredoorchestpurewhite
Buy Low Price fascinationslevitronrevolutionplatformwi
Buy Low Price razorpowerwingdlx
Buy Low Price ultega10footjumpertrampolinewithsafetyne
Buy Low Price 15ftframesizeroundreplacementtrampolinen
Buy Low Price littletikesclassictableandchairsset
Buy Low Price spalding4020dualshotelectronicbasketball
Buy Low Price playmobiljetplane
Buy Low Price pennycomplete22inchskateboardblackwhite
Buy Low Price legowhitecapbay4194
Buy Low Price twilightimperium3rdedition
Buy Low Price lioneltrainspolarexpresstrainsetogauge
Buy Low Price alexreadysetgoredtrike
Buy Low Price plantoybabywalker
Buy Low Price unclemiltonstartheatrepro
Buy Low Price elencosnapcircuitssc750rstudenttrainingp
Buy Low Price intexseahawkiiboatset
Buy Low Price southshorefurnituredoorchestpurewhite
Buy Low Price razorpowerwingdlx
Buy Low Price legostarwarsthebattleofendor8038
Buy Low Price ultega10footjumpertrampolinewithsafetyne
Buy Low Price 15ftframesizeroundreplacementtrampolinen
Buy Low Price littletikesclassictableandchairsset
Buy Low Price instepquicknezdoublebicycletrailer
Buy Low Price spalding4020dualshotelectronicbasketball
Buy Low Price currietechnologies24voltbicyclebatterypa
Buy Low Price step2wagonfortwoplusblue
Buy Low Price educationalinsightswirelesseggspert24ghz
Buy Low Price centurykidkickwavemaster
Buy Low Price brudermackgraniteliebherrcranetruck
Buy Low Price butterflytc1000tabletennistablecover
Buy Low Price razorgroundforcedrifterkart
Buy Low Price powerwheelsdisneypixarcars2lightningmcqu
Buy Low Price step2canopywagon
Buy Low Price kidkraftaspentableandchairsetnatural
Buy Low Price razore125electricscooterblack
Buy Low Price littletikesendlessadventuresswingalongca
Buy Low Price elencoelectronicssnapcircuitsdeluxesnapr
Buy Low Price chiccodancebabywalkerflowerpower
Buy Low Price starwarsstarwarsforcefxlukelightsaberwit
Buy Low Price brightstartsaroundwegoactivitystationdoo
Buy Low Price springswingssuperzfunride
Buy Low Price americanmahjongsetclassicroyalewithpushe
Buy Low Price kidkraftcooktogetherkitchen
Buy Low Price starwars174imperialatatallterrainarmored
Buy Low Price topeakjoeblowprofloorbikepump
Buy Low Price realsteeldeluxefeature8figureswave1setof
Buy Low Price microsoftsidewinderx6gamingkeyboardwithu
Buy Low Price earlylearningcentresandandwateractivityt
Buy Low Price 48inchbouncercamopink
Buy Low Price 38cmdoublehorse911624ghz4ch4channelrcsin
Buy Low Price stigainstaplaytabletennistable
Buy Low Price fenderstarcasterelectricguitarpackwitham
Buy Low Price fisherpricekidtoughmusicplayerwithmicrop
Buy Low Price flexibleflyerswingnglideiiiswingsetwithp
Buy Low Price magicthegatheringscarsofmirrodinboosterb
Buy Low Price amazongiftcardprintamazontoys0152000
Buy Low Price endlessadventureseasystoretable
Buy Low Price bazoongi48bouncerred
Buy Low Price warhammer40kassaultonblackreachstarterse
Buy Low Price radioflyerclassicredwagon
Buy Low Price princedmisportsbilliardtableconversionta
Buy Low Price warofthering2ndedition
Buy Low Price littletikeseasystorelargeslide
Buy Low Price step2lifestylecustomkitchen
Buy Low Price matchbox20carsetstylesmayvary
Buy Low Price takaratomybeybladesmetalfusionbb121ultim
Buy Low Price iwatamedeaeclipsehpcsdualactionairbrushg
Buy Low Price americanmahjonggamesetwithredwoodcase
Buy Low Price perfectsizeforindoorusemybouncer72lx72wx
Buy Low Price flexibleflyerbackyardfunswingsetwithplay
Buy Low Price ultega14footjumpertrampolinewithsafetyne
Buy Low Price step2toolchestdresser
Buy Low Price johndeere36steelwagonwithwoodenstakeside
Buy Low Price dusttacticsrevisedcoreset
Buy Low Price radioflyerblazeinteractiveridinghorse
Buy Low Price powerwheelsfordf150
Buy Low Price calicocritterscaravanfamilycamper
Buy Low Price tournamentstauntoncompletechessset
Buy Low Price zoomh4nportabledigitalrecorderpackagewit
Buy Low Price braineticsbreakthroughmathandmemorysyste
Buy Low Price fisherpriceadorableanimalshealthycarehig
Buy Low Price replogle12intelliglobe
Buy Low Price educationalinsightsgeosafaritalkingglobe
Buy Low Price thewalkingdeadcryptozoictradingcardsbox2
Buy Low Price ybikebalancebikeorange
Buy Low Price step2realprojectsworkshop
Buy Low Price razorpowerwingcasterscootersweetpea
Buy Low Price bachmanntrainsthoroughbredreadytorunhosc
Buy Low Price ontheedge900124redfoldingutilitywagonwit
Buy Low Price radioflyerlibertyspringhorsewithsound